Book Review: Mustaine - A Life in Metal


Dave Mustaine with Joe Layden
Harper Collins
Reviewed by Brendan Crabb

Dave Mustaine is a complex character. No great revelation you say? It isn’t. However, the Megadeth guitarist/vocalist/mastermind’s autobiography reveals as much, while adding further layers.

Many will primarily be seeking juicy tales from his brief, yet influential tenure during Metallica’s formative years – and likely won’t be disappointed. The insights into the key personalities of the gestating, oft-incestuous (in more ways than one) 80s thrash metal scene are page-turners. Additional details regarding his influences and progression as a guitarist, as well as the sonic development of thrash would have been welcome though. What is ultimately most fascinating is how, for all his demons (drugs, alcohol, women – all of which are documented in detail, albeit less vividly than Mötley Crüe’s The Dirt) Mustaine’s intense determination has driven him to sell more than 20 million albums. This was largely motivated by desire to top Metallica’s commercial success. You almost feel sympathy when he relates his inability to achieve said goal, but ultimately are inclined to side with the, "but look what you have achieved on your own" mindset. Particularly noteworthy is learning the basis for Megadeth’s late 90s flirtations with pop producers and hit singles - and the subsequent alienation of many fans. The only other significant downfall is inadequate detail about the recording of classic albums like 1990’s Rust In Peace.

The injury which nearly cost him the ability to play guitar - and subsequent conversion to Christianity - are covered, but not pushed too hard. Mustaine – A Life In Metal will likely polarize folks as much as the man himself does, but he hasn’t shirked from revealing the ebbing and flowing nature of life. There’s a few laughs littered throughout too.

Heavy Metal Merchant

Allen commented on 16-May-2011 08:45 PM3 out of 5 stars
Christianity not pushed hard?? Come on Crabby, the final 1/4 of the book went on and on abvout his conversion and new lifestyle.
Brendan Crabb commented on 17-May-2011 01:00 PM3 out of 5 stars
I'll stand by what I wrote. He does talk about it, but my point was I don't really think he tried too hard to push his actual beliefs on the reader- or encourage them to follow the same beliefs. Agree to disagree on this one.


No Very

Captcha Image

To browse a complete A-Z list of Loud Magazine’s features, please click here